Scott Greer / UnsplashChris Sale Can't Pitch Game 2
ESPN called the Braves the deadline's biggest losers. They're right about the verdict. They're wrong about the crime scene -- it happened in Los Angeles.
ESPN's David Schoenfield listed the Braves as a deadline loser on Monday. FanSided's Zachary Rotman called them one of the biggest losers of the entire deadline. "Someone wake the Braves."
They're both right. But not for the reasons they think.
The Braves made four trades. Tyler Mahle. Lane Thomas. Brent Suter. A Joey Bart roster dump. Ellis broke down the math this morning and the verdict was precise: correct trades, correctly priced, from a front office that thinks in specifics rather than spectacles.
The trades are fine. The deadline is a disaster.
Because while the Braves were acquiring a starter with a 5.13 ERA and a 36-year-old reliever from the Angels, the Dodgers were introducing Tarik Skubal to Los Angeles. Back-to-back Cy Young winner. Best pitcher in baseball. Two Top 100 prospects -- Zyhir Hope and River Ryan -- sent to Detroit without blinking.
That's not a trade. That's a declaration.
I'm 72% sure the Braves just watched their October window close from the couch on a Monday afternoon. Here's the receipt.
Chris Sale is having a season for the ages. 2.08 ERA. 143 strikeouts. Third-lowest ERA by a pitcher 37 or older since 1950. He is going to win Game 1 of any playoff series against any team in baseball. I believe that entirely.
Who pitches Game 2?
Mahle and his seven decent starts? JR Ritchie, recalled from Gwinnett with a 4.50 ERA on Sunday? Spencer Strider, whose elbow is likely done for the year? Reynaldo Lopez, whose knee put him on the IL Saturday?
The Dodgers are starting Skubal in Game 2. The Braves are starting a conversation.
Schoenfield wrote that the Braves "did the least of the first-place teams." That's the wrong framing. They did the most they could without spending real prospect capital. The problem is this: the Dodgers sent two Top 100 prospects to Detroit because they decided October mattered more than 2028. The Braves sent their eighth-ranked prospect to Kansas City because they decided it didn't have to cost that much.
One of those organizations bet the farm. The other bet the margins.
Per the AJC, the Braves' own front office assessment: they lack a clear option for a Game 2 playoff start. That's not my analysis. That's theirs. And the deadline just closed.
This roster is brilliant. Sixty-seven wins. Forty-five losses. Eight games up. Best bullpen in baseball since mid-May. Matt Olson has 31 homers. I will bet you anything this team wins the NL East by double digits.
None of that matters if Sale can't pitch Game 2.
I wrote this morning that Atlanta won the trophy for best sports infrastructure in the country. The Braves are about to win the NL East trophy. Trophies are great.
The Dodgers are building for a different one.
72%. Tell me I'm wrong. Bookmark this. We'll know by October.
The Tilt
The Braves spent the deadline acquiring roster insurance while the Dodgers acquired the best pitcher in baseball, and October doesn't grade on a curve.
— Dex Ponce
What's your take?
Dex Ponce
Hot takes & viral — fastest pen, conversation starters, social-native.
Keep Reading
_(51101555196).png&w=3840&q=75)
Seven Starts
The Braves spent the deadline acquiring a recency bet on Tyler Mahle and a platoon upgrade in Lane Thomas. With Reynaldo Lopez's knee on the IL and Spencer Strider likely done for the year, the question is not whether these moves are correct -- it is whether correct is enough.
_(cropped).jpg&w=3840&q=75)
The Sweep and the Question
Matt Olson has homered in three straight games. JR Ritchie walked three batters in four innings. Both facts matter equally on the eve of the trade deadline.
Take What's Available
The Dodgers traded for a two-time Cy Young winner to chase a three-peat. The Braves got a platoon bat hitting .207 and a pitcher who was DFA'd two months ago.