TheMorningTilt
Sunday Edition
ALL TEAMS

The Morning TiltSunday, May 17, 2026

Drake Baldwin's expected stats match his actual stats to within a thousandth of a point. That means the breakout is real. The Hawks don't know what they are yet. Your Sunday morning.

Ray PiedmontMay 17, 2026 · 3 min read

The Braves lost to a last-place team on Friday. They remain the best team in baseball by a wide margin. Drake Baldwin hit a 421-foot home run and it barely registered as news. Your Sunday morning.

The Baldwin conversation shifted this week, and it shifted in the direction that matters. His wOBA is .398. His expected wOBA — the Statcast metric that strips away luck — is .397. One thousandth of a point. That convergence means the production is not a hot streak. It is who he is.

Through 46 games: .297/.383/.509, 13 homers, 36 RBI, a 125 wRC+. He leads all MLB catchers in RBI, ranks second in batting average, and is on pace for 46 home runs — which would shatter Javy Lopez's 23-year franchise record of 43. Chipper Jones said this spring Baldwin was "not far from becoming the best catcher in baseball." Forty-six games later, the numbers agree with the legend.

The defensive metrics are the asterisk: 19th percentile in caught stealing, 45th in framing. The bat has stopped earning caveats. The glove has not. Ellis has the full statistical portrait — it's one of the better things we've published this spring. Dex has the hot take, and for once the receipts are airtight.

The record is 31-15 after Friday's loss. The NL East lead is nine games. Murphy is out eight weeks with a fractured finger. Strider is back. The cavalry continues arriving even as the roster keeps winning without it.

Two and a half weeks since 140-89. Two and a half weeks since the worst playoff loss in modern franchise history. And the conversation around the Hawks has settled into something more interesting than anger: confusion.

The season was good — 46-36, best regular season since 2015-16, a 27-15 surge after the Trae Young trade. The ending was catastrophic — a 47-point halftime deficit that set an NBA postseason record. The question the city is sitting with is whether you trust what happened from January through April or what happened on April 30.

Onsi Saleh's offseason framework: "We are not one player away." Picks eight and 23, $36 million below the luxury tax, Kuminga's $24.3 million option deadline on June 29, McCollum expected to re-sign. The tools exist. The direction is deliberately patient.

Simone's piece today frames this as a cultural question, not a roster question — and it's exactly the right lens.

OTAs start tomorrow. Phase III — the first 7-on-7 and 11-on-11 drills under Kevin Stefanski. The real playbook installation begins. Three weeks of organized activities lead into June's mandatory minicamp.

The meaningful subplot: Tua Tagovailoa and Michael Penix Jr. on the same practice field in competitive drills for the first time. No starter named. Reps will be split in a way that actually tells you something. The spring rhetoric has been patient by design — Stefanski's "I don't know" on the QB question is structural, not evasive — but tomorrow the reps start speaking louder than the press conferences.

The Five Stripes drew 1-1 at Orlando on Friday, and the stat line is becoming a recurring punchline: 11 shots to 3, 5 on goal to 2, 0.45 xG to 0.33, 90 percent passing accuracy, 7 chances created to 2. Dominated every meaningful metric. Needed an 86th-minute Jay Fortune equalizer to avoid a fifth straight loss.

They sit 26th in MLS. The four-match losing streak was technically snapped. The gap between what the underlying numbers say this team is and what the standings say this team is has become the defining tension of the season — and it is not getting smaller.

The Open Cup quarterfinal at the same Orlando stadium is Tuesday. Same pitch, same opponent, elimination stakes. Tito called Friday the rehearsal. The finishing has to be sharper. The chances will come again.

One more thing. Two Tilt writers published about Drake Baldwin this morning from completely different angles. Ellis wrote 1,100 words about exit velocity and xwOBA convergence. Dex wrote 500 words that amount to: everyone got it wrong and I told you so. Same player, same data, two entirely different arguments. That is the point of having a newsroom instead of a content feed.

The Tilt

Baldwin's wOBA/xwOBA convergence closes the 'is he for real' debate — 46 games is enough to call it.

Ray Piedmont

What's your take?

Share